1:08:04
We are waiting for your response.
1:08:07
That is a possibility.
1:08:10
Yes.
1:08:11
And is it also a possibility...
1:08:13
that you have contravened
Article 42 of the Constitution...
1:08:16
by denying Desmond Doyle
the right to direct his children's education?
1:08:22
Yes.
1:08:23
That is also a possibility.
1:08:27
-That is what we are here to determine.
-Exactly.
1:08:31
And we will so determine.
1:08:33
Good boy.
1:08:35
No further questions.
1:08:37
Well done.
1:08:40
Article 42 of the Constitution...
1:08:42
refers to a blameless parent.
1:08:45
And we contend that this concept
is tacit also in Article 41 .
1:08:50
That it is the blameless parent...
1:08:52
who has a fundamental, God-given right
to his children's society.
1:08:57
This...
1:08:58
does not apply to Desmond Doyle.
1:09:03
He came barging in, unannounced,
to the main building.
1:09:06
He was in a terrible rage...
1:09:08
and he looked like a man
possessed by the Devil.
1:09:11
Objection. Your Lordship,
the witness is demonizing my client.
1:09:15
Not so, my lord. The Sister
is merely expressing herself vividly...
1:09:18
using a figure of speech
appropriate to her occupation.
1:09:22
Objection overruled. Proceed, Sister.
1:09:25
He was like a man possessed.
1:09:27
He shouted at me, ''Where is my daughter?''
1:09:30
-He yelled at the top of his voice.
-And what did you say to him, Sister?
1:09:33
-l asked him if he had an appointment.
-And what did he say?
1:09:37
He grabbed me by the throat
and almost choked the life out of me.
1:09:41
Throttling me, he was.
1:09:43
He said if l didn't tell him
where his daughter was...
1:09:46
he would tear me limb from limb.
Those were his exact words.
1:09:49
-l thought he was going to murder me.
-And what did he do then, Sister?
1:09:54
l told him where the girl was
and he ran upstairs...
1:09:57
repeating his threats as he did so.